What to look for in a CRO agency, the questions to ask before you sign, and the warning signs, with results from JCB, Trace and APOC.

Plenty of agencies can show you where visitors leave your website. Fewer can tell you why it matters to your business, and fewer still can design and build the better journey that fixes it. When you're choosing a conversion rate optimisation (CRO) agency, that gap is the thing to test for.
Here's what to look for, the questions worth asking, and the warning signs that an agency is chasing numbers rather than results.
They start with how you make money
A good CRO agency asks about your business before it asks for your analytics login. Which products or services matter most? Which customers are worth the most? What does a valuable enquiry actually look like? What can your team realistically deliver each month?
This matters because more conversions aren't always better. A shorter quote form might double submissions and halve their quality. For specialist contractors, a flood of small domestic enquiries can be worse than a few good commercial ones. When we rebuilt the website for Trace Basement Systems, we refocused it on larger, higher-value projects. The result was more relevant leads and less time wasted on enquiries that were never going to become work.
They use more than one source of evidence
GA4 tells you what people do. It rarely tells you why. And analytics is often less accurate than teams assume: different tools disagree, cookie consent hides part of the picture, and many conversions happen on the phone.
A good agency combines analytics with behaviour tools such as Hotjar or Microsoft Clarity (heatmaps and session recordings), your CRM and sales data, and conversations with your customers or sales team. When the numbers point one way and the recordings show another, the recordings usually win. AI now speeds up a lot of this analysis; our article on AI UX audits explains what it finds and what it misses.
They can design and build the fix, not just report it
This is where many CRO engagements fall down. An audit full of findings is only valuable if someone turns it into better pages. Ask whether the agency designs the improvements, builds them, and tests them, or hands you a report and leaves.
At JCB, the audit showed buyers were comparing machines but the pages didn't help them do it or ask for a price. We designed new page templates with key specs, weekly lease prices and a quote request on every model. They were adopted in over 12 countries, and within three months new machine enquiries rose by 66%.
Want a second opinion on your website? Book a 20-minute CRO review.
They prioritise ruthlessly
Any agency can produce a list of fifty problems. The skill is knowing which three to fix first. Ask to see how they score ideas. A simple impact-versus-effort score is fine, as long as it's tied to your commercial goals. Be wary of an agency that wants to test button colours before it has looked at your pricing page.
They test properly, or tell you when you can't
A/B testing needs enough traffic to give a reliable answer. A good agency will tell you honestly if you don't have it, and suggest other ways to validate changes, such as before-and-after comparisons or staged rollouts. We use tools such as Optibase with some larger clients for A/B, split URL and multivariate tests. With smaller sites we often make evidence-backed improvements and measure them over time instead.
They understand the platform you're on
CRO on Shopify, Adobe Commerce, WordPress and Webflow involves different constraints. Changes that take an hour in Webflow can take a sprint on a heavily customised Magento build, which is one reason we build most new sites on Webflow through our Webflow agency service. Ask what the agency has built on your platform. APOC Store on Shopify tripled its conversion rate, in the client's own words, after design and journey improvements that kept its distinctive brand. If budget is the question, our guide to costing an ecommerce CRO project gives typical ranges.
Questions to ask before you sign
- How will you learn how our business makes money?
- What sources of data will you use, and how will you check they're accurate?
- Who designs and builds the changes?
- How do you decide what to fix first?
- How will we know whether a change worked?
- Can you show results from businesses like ours?
Warning signs
Guaranteed uplift percentages before they've seen your data. A focus on vanity metrics like time on page. No interest in lead quality. Reports with no designs. And long contracts before any discovery work.
How we work
We're a small, senior UX and CRO team in Manchester. We use data to find the problem and UX design to solve it, then build and test the fix. Most clients start with a CRO audit and move onto a monthly programme once they've seen what's possible. Our CRO services page explains the full process, and our projects show the results.
Choosing a CRO partner? Talk to us and ask us the questions above.





